Skip to main content

Covid and the Miasma Theory

With the benefit of hindsight, we now know that COVID-19 can be spread through the air, which is why wearing masks is so effective (far more than social distancing) and arguably necessary to stem the spread of the disease. This is particularly true indoors where ventilation is limited and the air carries the virus for longer than outdoors where the wind can blow it away. 

Representation of miasma or bad air that can cause disease

What is interesting is that this theory was not accepted by many virologists (or even the WHO who resisted the claim that the virus can be carried in the air. It took more than 200 experts arguing in support of the airborne nature of the virus to convince the WHO to declare it so. The reason for this discrepancy (and resistance to the airborne theory) is interesting, and surprisingly, relates to none other than the granddaddy of medicine, Hippocrates. 

It was Hippocrates who first noticed (back in 5th century BCE) that people in one region often got sick with the same symptoms and concluded that it was caused by bad air, or "miasma." He proposed that  “whenever many men are attacked by one disease at the same time, the cause should be assigned to that which is most common, and which we all use most. This it is which we breathe in.” This theory became so popular that it lasted for centuries and caused problems for other diseases that are not airborne. For example, an English physician who tried to argue that cholera was spread by infected water was ridiculed and likewise, doctors refused to accept that handwashing could limit disease and improve childbirth mortality. People's likely argument was if disease was caused by bad air, why would water or hygiene matter?

When the germ theory (that different germs caused different diseases) was finally proven and widely accepted, it was the turn of the miasma theory to be ridiculed and shunned by the medical world. Apparently, medical experts still recoil at the mention of airborne spread because it suggests that they support an antiquated theory of disease. However, the reality is that Hippocrates was partially correct in his conclusion that disease (can) spread by bad (infected) air because some pathogens are in fact airborne. Others like malaria and dengue are definitely not (they are carried by mosquitos).

It took more than a year of the pandemic for the WHO and the US Center for Disease Control (CDC), to finally accept that airborne spread of the SARS-CoV2 virus is possible, effectively supporting the miasma theory (modified version of course!). So what we have to learn and keep in mind is that lessons from the past are not to be ignored or ridiculed, neither are they to be taken as the fundamental truth. It does provide us with a great jumping point towards new truths and a better understanding of medicine.

Aerial transmission of coronavirus according to the EU


Sources:

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/04/health/239-experts-with-one-big-claim-the-coronavirus-is-airborne.html
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/global-health/science-and-disease/every-medical-authority-failed-realise-covid-airborne-late/
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-briefs/sars-cov-2-transmission.html#anchor_1619805184733
https://ec.europa.eu/jrc/en/news/covid-19-how-better-understanding-airborne-transmission-key-break-chain-infection


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Galen

Even though Cajal is considered the father of neuroscience, his contribution came centuries after the first insights into the nervous system. As I wrote in my earlier posts, ancient doctors pondered over the nervous system, trying to understand what controlled the mind and body. Of these doctors, one that stands out is Galen, whose contribution to the understanding of the nervous system was fundamental to neuroscience. Through anatomical experiments, Galen was the first to observe and teach the functioning of nerves in the body. For these experiments, which he wasn’t shy about demonstrating to the public, Galen is regarded as the founder of experimental physiology. Galen is considered one of the most prominent and influential doctors in history, second only to Hippocrates. Galen was a staunch follower of Hippocrates and helped spread his teachings from Greece to the vast Roman Empire. Claudius Galenus, commonly know as Galen, was born in 129 AD in Pergamum in modern-day Turkey to a...

Origin of Neurology

As I consider majoring in neurobiology (the study of the biological mechanisms that control the nervous system) in college, I thought it would be interesting to delve into the origins of neuroscience. For hundreds of years from the ancient Egyptians to the Greeks, humans believed that the seat of intellect was the heart (which is why the ancient Egyptians went to great lengths to preserve the heart after death but discarded the brain!)    The birth of neurology began 2500 years ago with Hippocrates who pondered over the purpose and functioning of the brain, reasoning that the brain must be the organ controlling sensation simply because most sensory organs - eyes, ears, and tongue -- are located close to the brain. This was starkly different from other opinions of the time which held that the heart was the main organ that controlled everything in humans. The brain was simply thought to be a "radiator" for pumping the heart and keeping it cool.  Later, Hippocrates expanded ...

The Nervous System

Just as the purpose of the brain and the heart confused ancient scientists, so did the nervous system. Nerves had been identified fairly early but they proved difficult to categorize. Some thought it was similar to arteries and formed some sort of connective system for tissues. In fact, the word nerve is Greek for tendon or sinew, suggesting that it was thought to be some sort of physical connection. Despite the confusion about its exact mechanism, ancient medical practitioners seemed to understand its function. Nerves were attributed to both movement and sensation correctly, even though there were opposing views on what controlled these functions. Aristotle argued that nerves originated and were controlled by the heart, while others argued nerves were controlled by the brain. Centuries later, Galen proved that nerves emanated from the brain, scoffing at those “who know nothing of what is to be seen in dissection." Galen was the first to conclude that the spinal cord was an ...