Skip to main content

Reflection on Experience vs. Evidence

I read a fascinating discussion on the contrasts between ancient and modern medicine which really struck a chord since I have spent much time researching and writing about the concepts of experience versus evidence in medicine.

Reflecting on cupping therapy, the paper's author, Dr. Anna Dinallo of the University of New Mexico, made the observation that modern medicine is based solely on knowledge of anatomy, which is learned primarily through dissection. Therefore, all modern medical knowledge is really obtained from a dead body. The author also argues that modern practitioners use anatomical dissections to discredit alternative medicine which does not have an anatomical foundation.

I found that really interesting. All ancient medicine is based on experience. Diagnosis itself relies on examination through observation of pulse, smell, and sound-- all senses that the author argues rightly, are absent in a corpse during dissection. In fact, Ayurveda has 8 distinct examinations that are used in the diagnosis of disease: appearance, voice, eyes, skin, urine, stool, pulse, and tongue.

The eight methods of diagnosis in Ayurveda

Also, at its core, ancient medicine like Ayurveda and TCM uses a holistic healing philosophy. For instance, TCM is based on the Taoism model of holism which believes that systems and their properties must be viewed together, not just as a collection of parts. Taoists believe humans are an integral part of nature and an extension of the universe, so everything about the human body has to be seen through its relation with nature. Disease, according to this concept, is caused by an imbalance in the body, which is the result of climate, emotions, and/or trauma. 

Even if you don't believe this philosophy, it is true that many experience-based therapies have been proven to be highly effective despite lacking scientific evidence (so far). I am not supporting having blind faith in medicine by any stretch, but making the observation that many many therapies that seemed like "quack" medicine have been proven to work, and the evidence has followed later. This includes acupuncture, yoga, massage therapy, even cupping to a certain extent. Sure, some of the ancient understanding of the human body was inaccurate because they lacked a clear idea of human anatomy, but that doesn't make its medicine, which was developed over thousands of years of observation and experience, less deserving of credit. Physicians were trained to diagnose imbalances through external observation alone.

Consultation with Ayurvedic practitioner

Just as modern medicine can be a hit or miss for many diseases (most obvious example is cancer), ancient medicine likely had its great successes and failures and it requires careful study and understanding to separate the two and use the wisdom of our ancestors as a stepping stone to expand our knowledge of medicine.


Sources

https://medcraveonline.com/IJCAM/a-reflection-on-cupping-therapy-and-historical-medical-dominance.html
https://www.planetayurveda.com/diagnosis-methods-ayurveda/
https://www.amcollege.edu/blog/taoism-and-traditional-chinese-medicine

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Origin of Neurology

As I consider majoring in neurobiology (the study of the biological mechanisms that control the nervous system) in college, I thought it would be interesting to delve into the origins of neuroscience. For hundreds of years from the ancient Egyptians to the Greeks, humans believed that the seat of intellect was the heart (which is why the ancient Egyptians went to great lengths to preserve the heart after death but discarded the brain!)    The birth of neurology began 2500 years ago with Hippocrates who pondered over the purpose and functioning of the brain, reasoning that the brain must be the organ controlling sensation simply because most sensory organs - eyes, ears, and tongue -- are located close to the brain. This was starkly different from other opinions of the time which held that the heart was the main organ that controlled everything in humans. The brain was simply thought to be a "radiator" for pumping the heart and keeping it cool.  Later, Hippocrates expanded ...

Galen

Even though Cajal is considered the father of neuroscience, his contribution came centuries after the first insights into the nervous system. As I wrote in my earlier posts, ancient doctors pondered over the nervous system, trying to understand what controlled the mind and body. Of these doctors, one that stands out is Galen, whose contribution to the understanding of the nervous system was fundamental to neuroscience. Through anatomical experiments, Galen was the first to observe and teach the functioning of nerves in the body. For these experiments, which he wasn’t shy about demonstrating to the public, Galen is regarded as the founder of experimental physiology. Galen is considered one of the most prominent and influential doctors in history, second only to Hippocrates. Galen was a staunch follower of Hippocrates and helped spread his teachings from Greece to the vast Roman Empire. Claudius Galenus, commonly know as Galen, was born in 129 AD in Pergamum in modern-day Turkey to a...

The Nervous System

Just as the purpose of the brain and the heart confused ancient scientists, so did the nervous system. Nerves had been identified fairly early but they proved difficult to categorize. Some thought it was similar to arteries and formed some sort of connective system for tissues. In fact, the word nerve is Greek for tendon or sinew, suggesting that it was thought to be some sort of physical connection. Despite the confusion about its exact mechanism, ancient medical practitioners seemed to understand its function. Nerves were attributed to both movement and sensation correctly, even though there were opposing views on what controlled these functions. Aristotle argued that nerves originated and were controlled by the heart, while others argued nerves were controlled by the brain. Centuries later, Galen proved that nerves emanated from the brain, scoffing at those “who know nothing of what is to be seen in dissection." Galen was the first to conclude that the spinal cord was an ...